Friday, February 28, 2020

The Regent Park School of Music is included in a Taylor Swift album.

 The song is called "It's Nice to Have a Friend." Wikipedia photo.

CMHC properties
Regent Park - Dean McDermott lived in Regent Park, Toronto.
Willow Park - Winnipeg, Manitoba.
Habitat - part of Expo, Montreal.
CMHC National Headquarters - 700 Montreal Road, Ottawa.
Fraser Institute, 1996.



Thursday, February 27, 2020

Low income housing units may be taking over the RCMP Headquarters, a baseball stadium and parkland.

The former National Headquarters for the RCMP, 1200 Vanier Parkway. Ottawa Community Housing would only have to pay $1 dollar for the entire property because of a program called The Federal Lands Initiative for Affordable Housing. A Department of National Defence Armoury on 1010 Somerset/933 Gladstone was also donated to OCH.

Potential City of Ottawa housing properties.
A 2.4 hectare site on Greenbank Road in Barrhaven near Strandherd and Longfields.
The baseball stadium on 302 Coventry Road Ottawa may eventually be deconstructed.
Bob MacQuarrie recreational complex in Orleans.
The former Canadian Broadcasting Corporation building on Lanark Drive, Westboro.
Tom Brown Arena.
A PWGSC building on 1010 Somerset, Little Italy right next to the Plant Bath including the Dome.
(From: City eyes baseball stadium, Tom Brown Arena for development, CBC.ca, March 29, 2019.)
In a few years all of these properties may be converted into luxury condos. Regent Park in Toronto  was created by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. However, a $1 million dollar condo was recently sold in Regent Park, which is managed by Toronto Community Housing.

A PWGSC Building on 1010 Somerset. OCH directors are lobbying for more federal properties in the area.

  Park land that the people of Ottawa have lost:
870 Carling Avenue, despite efforts by local politician Katherine Hobbs to save it.
The 88-acre Moffatt Farm Veterans Affairs Park is now "Prince of Wales on the Rideau."
The land next to Major's Hill Park that was sold to the American Embassy. 
The Daly Building footprint near the Chateau Laurier and Revenue Canada.
Federal politicians John Baird and John Manley want to see the Lebreton Flats converted into Ottawa's Central Park.


                            

Sunday, February 23, 2020

The City of Ottawa gave away a landmark in Chinatown.

Item: Disposal of 755 Somerset Street West to the Somerset West Community Health Centre, February 12, 2020.
Committee Recommendations: The Council
1.) Declare the property known municipally as 755 Somerset Street West described as Part of Lot 3 East of Lorne Avenue; Lots 1 and 2 North of Somerset Street; Lots 2 and 3 West of Empress Avenue; all on Plan 11285, as in NS 584, in the City of Ottawa and shown as Document 1, attached as surplus to the City's needs;
2.) Waive the requirement in Section 5 of the City's Real Property Disposal Policy requiring notification to the public of the pending sale of a City property;
3.) Waive the requirement in Section 1.2 of the City's Real Property Disposal Policy requiring all Real Property to be disposed of at market value and approve the sale of the lands known municipally as 755 Somerset West to the Somerset West Community Health Centre for a sum of $1 dollar.
The photo is from CBC News.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
The Chinatown neighbourhood is a Heritage Conservation District protected by Part V of the Ontario Heritage Act.
 The federal government should have had an opportunity to buy this building and create a national museum, to document important Chinese Canadian milestones.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Municipality of Ottawa property that was privatized:
91 acres of Experimental Farm land called "the Clyde/Merivale lands."








Saturday, February 22, 2020

The impending demise of Little Italy, Ottawa.

---There will be a massive increase in traffic along Carling Avenue and Preston Street.
---The tallest building in Ottawa is located at the corner of Preston and Carling, 45-storys.
---A dozen condo projects are either projected, approved or under construction.
---The Civic Hospital Neighbourhood Association is worried about the increase in traffic and the loss of Queen Juliana Park located at 870 Carling. The park is a popular venue for the Italian Week festivities, Walk for Juvenile Diabetes, etc. The land was rezoned after the National Capital Commission gave 50 acres of the Experimental Farm to a health care facility. High rises will be built on the property.
---The Humane Society land on 101 Champagne was earmarked for Ev Tremblay Park. Never happened.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     This is Ottawa, the capital city of Canada.This is not Vancouver, Hong Kong or Manhattan.A local politician should not have the power to ruin the character and skyline of my city. Until 1965 there was a ban on the construction of any building taller than the Parliament Hill Peace Tower, in downtown Ottawa. The National Capital Commission has abdicated their responsibility to preserve  tourism meccas and a UNESCO World Heritage site. Has it occurred to you, National Capital Commission, that out-of-control redevelopment will have an impact on:
historic neighbourhoods.
the UNESCO protected Rideau Canal.
Dow's Lake
the Farm.
The safety of pedestrians and vehicle occupants.
490-500 Preston Street
Proposed construction of a residential development consisting of approximately 280 residential units and ground floor retail. Increase in vehicle traffic of approximately 105-120 veh./h during morning and afternoon peak hours.
505 Preston Street 
A mixed-use development of approximately 262 residential units. Ground floor retail and office space. Increase in vehicle traffic 60 to 70 veh./hr.
845 Carling Avenue
A three-tower residential consisting of approximately 486 residential units and ground floor retail space. Projected increase in vehicle traffic of approximately 150 to 175 veh./h during the morning and afternoon peak hours.
514 Rochester Street
A residential development consisting of approximately 117 residential units and ground floor retail. Projected increase in traffic approximately 58 and 58 veh./hr during the weekday and afternoon peak hours.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    A 2002 traffic study.
                                        Table 2: Summary of Existing Conditions
Road Name and Section                                                     Peak Directional Volume (veh./hr)
Carling Avenue Highway 417 to Booth                             2,000                       
Preston Avenue Prince of Wales to Carling                       1,100
Preston Avenue Carling to Hwy 417                                    800
Parkdale Avenue Carling to Hwy 417                                  600
(From: Central Experimental Farm National Historic Site Management Plan - Page 7/20.)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diane Holmes interview with Ottawa Citizen reporter David Reevely.
Save Little Italy photo from Facebook. Former Somerset Ward councillor Diane Holmes is pictured on the left.
Petition - Save Ev Tremblay Park Little Italy.
Land behind the Adult High  School.

City of Ottawa Planning Committee, June 24, 2014 - "Somerset Ward Councillor Holmes noted that work on the Preston-Carling Secondary Plan had been underway for the past decade, at which time tension in the neighbourhood had risen."















Friday, February 21, 2020

Landmarks that were nearly demolished.

The Alamo
Stonehenge
Leaning Tower of Pisa
Colosseum
Grand Central Terminal.
Union Station - Toronto.
Eiffel Tower

The outer shell of the Grand Central Terminal in New York City would have been retained according to the drawing on the left.

Thursday, February 20, 2020

This is what will happen to the Mall and Wellington Street.

The Sparks Street Mall is on the left while Queen Street is on the right. The photo is from NCC Watch.
Sparks Street Mall redevelopment between Sparks Street and Queen Street west of Metcalfe. Proposed environmentally friendly residential construction of a six storey building on Sparks Street and 18 storey building on Queen Street. The building will house a hotel and condominium units in the upper floors. In total there will be 235 units.


Wednesday, February 19, 2020

"The Mall is the National Capital Commission's public enemy No. 1." Macleans magazine.

"Sparks Street: The five-block, eastwest pedestrian mall and surrounding area is the NCC's public enemy No. 1." (From: "Tidying up a mess"/Macleans Magazine-September 3, 2001.)
"It's Crown against town and sparks are flying as the National Capital Commission prepares to demolish an entire block in downtown Ottawa. City officials, businessmen and private citizens alike fear that the NCC's plan to raze Sparks Street and replace it with office towers, apartments, stores and restaurants will destroy rather than revitalize the downtown core." (From: The Globe and Mail newspaper, May 2, 2001.)
The National Capital Commission owned all the property on the southern side of the Mall. It has been privatized.

"Now the corporation is determined to spearhead the revitalization of Sparks Street. In the last month the corporation has purchased two buildings on the south side of Sparks Street for a future mixed-use development. By 2006, with $40 million granted by the federal government, the NCC plans to have an entire block of buildings along Sparks Street converted into a complex of retail, commercial and condominiums. It's expected the developer will demolish the buildings---with the possibility of saving some of the Victorian-era facades. (Ottawa's second-class citizens, Globe and Mail newspaper, March 22, 2000.)
The buildings south of Wellington may be subjected to a facadectomy. Map is from "Sparks Street-The Commercial and Banking Centre".

The Birks Building.



Tuesday, February 18, 2020

The Sparks Street Mall is protected by Part V of the Ontario Heritage Act. However, politicians in Ottawa ignore that law.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Is it a coincidence, that the brand-new Parliament LRT station is below Queen and O'Connor. 

City of Ottawa -Application for new construction in a Heritage Conservation District, October 10, 2001.

Report Recommendations
1.)  That approval be given to construct a new building at 131 Queen Street.
2.)  That approval be given to demolish the existing building located at 121 Queen Street, and partially demolish the buildings located at 126 to 146 Sparks Street.
     "The facades of the four heritage buildings facing Sparks Street will be retained in situ and incorporated as part of the new development...The Hardy Arcade facades on Sparks and Queen Street will be retained...The interior will have to be dismantled and reconstructed because of the need to construct above and below part of the new development."

The Mall during the year 1967. The Art Deco designed Hardy Arcade is beside the Chicken Villa. ( National Archives)
Heritage Ottawa to built heritage subcommittee, July 11, 2013 and September 5, 2013, Re: 110-116 Sparks Street.
The decision to retain the facade of this building as a surface ornamentation is reminiscent of the similar decision made for the Ogilvy Building, wherein the building languished so long that virtually nothing but some of its surface features could be retained.
Retention of surface features alone is not recommended by the Standards and Guidelines for the Conservation of Historic Places in Canada endorsed by the City of Ottawa (Standard 12: "Not recommended...demolishing a building structure and retaining only the street facades.")
Nevertheless, the OHA designates properties not buildings, per se, so a remnant can still be protected by the OHA.
Heritage Ottawa hopes that, with a vigorous demolition by neglect by-law tailored to heritage properties, we won't be seeing too many more of these.
As for the proposed new facade at 106 Sparks Street, it is sympathetic to the historic facade of 110-116, in its roof line and fenestration, while being clearly a new design, and in line with the design guidelines developed for Sparks Street. The Queen Street tower appears to be set far enough back as not to impinge upon sight lines on Sparks Street.
Heritage Ottawa recommends:

  • That the facade be restored by the means most likely to ensure the survival of its remaining heritage features.
  • That although the south side of Sparks Street has largely succumbed to facadism, the BHSC encourage the preservation of the many fine heritage buildings on the north side too.
Leslie Maitland, M. Mus. CAHP
President, Heritage Ottawa
The movie theatre was part of 110-116 Sparks Street.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
From 1973 until the year 2000 the federal Department of Public Works owned most of the properties bounded by Wellington, Elgin, Sparks and Bank Street. The properties on the south side of the Mall were then sold to the National Capital Commission. (The National Capital Commission did own the Hardy Arcade in 1997.)
Now the government of Canada is planning a massive overhaul on the north side of the Mall. Buildings as tall as 34 story's will line the Sparks Street, and the outer shell of the existing buildings will be preserved. These are the guidelines developed for Sparks Street. Judging by what is going  on in Little Italy, the condos will be higher than 34 storys.
The National Capital Commission wants to see more condos along the promenade:
" Residential, commercial and retail spaces, as well as "people" places that open up the view to the Parliament Buildings are among the concepts being explored."
"Sparks Street is one of the most important heritage streets in the downtown Capital...The plan envisages revitalization of the street through rehabilitation of heritage buildings and new development for residential (150 units) and commercial use at the eastern end of the street." From: NCC Annual Report-1999-2000-Page 6/78 and page 33/78.)


Monday, February 17, 2020

Bill S-203 will prevent the clear cutting of properties opposite Parliament Hill.

PWGSC is planning to change the character of the Parliamentary Precinct south of Wellington.
Senate Bill S-203, created in the year 2019, will save the properties opposite Parliament Hill.
The federal government expropriated all land and buildings between Wellington, Elgin, Sparks and Bank Street in the year 1973 in order to preserve the architectural history of the site and to provide office space and committee rooms for government departments and agencies.
The properties listed below are part of the Sparks Street Heritage Conservation District, and they have been designated as historic buildings by Parks Canada.
Blackburn Building - 85 Sparks. Recognized Federal Heritage Building.
Bate - 109-111 Sparks. Recognized    " 
Dover - 185-187 Sparks. Recognized " 
Slater - 177-179 Sparks.  Recognized " 
Brouse - 181-183 Sparks.Recognized " 
Postal Station B - 47-59 Sparks. Classified " 
Hope - 61- 63 Sparks. Recognized "     
Bank of Nova Scotia - 125 Sparks. Classified " 
Birks - 107 Sparks. Recognized "    "    "
Canada's Four Corners - 93 Sparks. Recognized "   
Saxe - 75 Sparks
Scottish-Ontario Chamber - 42-50 Sparks. Recognized "
The President's Report      Heritage Ottawa-Carolyn Quinn    Spring 2000
"The NCC recently unveiled Phase 11 of its planning initiative for "The Core Area of Canada's Capital..." It is the Sparks Street area initiative that raises immediate concerns..The clear-cutting of the south side of the block of Sparks Street between Metcalfe and O'Connor makes a mockery of the NCC's claim that the core will be "a model of urban ecology through the protection of the built and natural environment". Both the demolition and relocation of heritage buildings and the creation of a public square ignores the historic significance of Sparks Street, an important cultural landscape.

The only building on the block in question that the NCC seems to be prepared to acknowledge as having heritage significance is the Hardy Arcade (which has been recognized by the Federal Heritage Buildings Review Office (FHBRO), a modest but rare example in Canada of both Art Deco architecture and a shopping arcade. This attitude ignores the municipal heritage evaluation of the block that gives all building category 1 rating, the highest rating of heritage significance, with the exception of 148 Sparks that has a category 2 rating.
Some of the buildings under threat of demolition date back to the 1870's...The former Bowles Lunch built in 1913 at 134 Sparks Street, remains unique in Ottawa. The NCC has been given $40 million dollars to purchase properties; $9.2 million has already been spent to buy 100 Sparks Street with a market value at the time of purchase at $2.7 million. The eagerness to progress with the "conceptual" plan becomes only too evident.

Interestingly, the final report of the Central Area West Heritage Conservation District Study, commissioned by the City of Ottawa, that deals with the identification, protection and management of heritage resources in the Central Area of Ottawa makes important recommendations that address the need to balance the civic realm and the capital realm more effectively. The report made three key recommendations: firstly, that Sparks Street, south of Wellington and north of Queen between Bank and Elgin, be designated a Heritage Conservation District.

Secondly, that Bank Street between Gloucester and Albert be designated a Heritage Conservation District; and thirdly, that the full length of Sparks Street, including Elgin from Sparks to Lisgar and extending east to the Rideau Canal be designated a National Historic District.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Heritage Conservation District
National Historic District
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
List of properties designated under Part 1V of the Ontario Heritage Act
within the proposed Sparks Street Heritage Conservation District.

50 Wellington (Langevin Block) By-law 354-78.
32-36 Elgin Street (former Bell Block) By-law 155-87.
38-54 Elgin Street (Central Chambers) By-law 87-78
42-50 Sparks Street (former Scottish-Ontario Chambers) By-law 198-87.
125 Sparks Street (former Bank of Nova Scotia) By-law 88-92.
156-158 Sparks Street (former Poulin Dry Goods) By-law 300-80.
(from: Local Architectural Conservation Advisory Committee-Agenda 6, May 2, 2000.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------



















Sunday, February 16, 2020

The government of Canada and historic properties.

The Chambers Building is located on 40 Elgin Street, Ottawa and is part of the Confederation Square National Historic Site of Canada.
Confederation Square monuments and landmarks.
The National War Memorial and Tomb of the Unknown Soldier.
National Arts Centre
Chateau Laurier Hotel - sold to the Canadian Pacific Railway. The hotel is a National Historic Site of Canada.
Central Chambers
Government Conference Centre - Also known as a Grand Trunk railway station, Union Station and Conference Centre. During the early 1980's I was a Conference Centre employee.
Langevin - is part of a massive PWGSC redevelopment plan.The former Langevin block includes
59, 85, 75, 63, 65, 67, and 69 Sparks.
   The government of Canada wants to see modern architecture on the Parliamentary Precinct after the vacant buildings along Wellington, the Mall and Elgin Street are clear-cut. They should care about preserving our history and not about the needs of real estate developers.
----------------------------------------
The politician for Somerset Ward is hoping to see more condos on the Mall. And intensification in Ottawa will be focused around LRT stations. The Parliament LRT station is located between O'Connor and Queen.
The Sparks Street Mall is Canada's counterpart to the National Mall in Washington, D.C.
Canada's Mall is part of the Parliamentary Precinct and is across the street from Confederation Square. It is protected by Section V of the Ontario Heritage Act as a Heritage Conservation District and by City of Ottawa By-Law #174-2000.
The National Mall in Washington D.C. 
The National Mall is sacred ground and no one would dare put up residential or office towers. Memorials, cultural institutions, art galleries and statues are located on America's Mall:
World War 11 Memorial
Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Washington Memorial
Lincoln Memorial
The Smithsonian.
Union Station is 1 mile away.

Ottawa's Union Station where I was employed. 
 House of Commons debates  July 20, 1973   
Hon. Jean Eudes Dube, Minister of Public Works.
"...concern has been expressed about the danger of visual encroachment on the beauty of the present parliamentary precinct, which is one of the great symbols of Canada. We must ensure that nearby developments do not affect it...We are all proud of the outstanding appearance and setting of the Parliament of Canada. It is as impressive as any in the world. I think we will agree that we have a duty to preserve its dignity, grace and beauty for the years ahead."

I have a few ideas.
Establish a Terry Fox National Museum in the vacant building on 90 Wellington. A statue of the one-legged runner is located on the plaza in front of 90 Wellington. My sister wrote and performed "A Song for Terry Fox" which is on YouTube.
Another museum could celebrate this country's contribution to the film and tv industry. Photographs, awards, etc. pertaining to Alex Trebek, Lorne Greene, James Cameron (Titanic), John Candy, Catherine O'Hara, Eugene Levy, Mary Pickford and a host of others can be displayed.
Create a tourist information centre on Wellington across from Parliament Hill. I visited Quebec City  and the tourism centre is across the street from the Chateau Frontenac Hotel. The tour bus operator pointed out all the places where Celine Dion sang including the Plains of Abraham and churches.
Create a restaurant on the Mall that serves Canadian food---poutine, split pea soup, Beavertails, Butter tarts, Nanaimo bars, Saskatoon rhubarb pie, Montreal-style bagels, etc. Provide a brochure that gives recipes.

Toronto's CBC Museum permanently closed a few years ago. The CBC is a national institution and the museum should be located in the National Capital. The CBC Headquarters on the Sparks Street Mall would be an appropriate venue. I would like to see Glenn Gould's piano. Glenn Gould donated all of his papers, photographs and memorabilia to the National Archives and the collection would gain a wider audience if it was displayed in the Parliamentary Precinct. More security guards would have to be hired because Glenn Gould artifacts are popular---an American woman stole documents from the Archives and tried to sell them on EBay. They were returned.
Convert one of the buildings into a movie theatre that features home-grown movies and unreleased documentaries:
Canadian Bacon with John Candy and Rhea Perlman.
Goin' Down the Road.
Beautiful Dreamers - the story of Canadian psychiatrist and mystic Dr. Maurice Bucke. Dr. Bucke was a friend of American poet Walt Whitman and wrote "Cosmic Consciousness- A Study in the Evolution of the Human Mind."
Thirty Two Short Films About Glenn Gould.
The Canadian Conspiracy with Martin Short, Howie Mandel, Leslie Nielsen, Anne Murray...

Humanitarian Lotta Hitschmanova created the Unitarian Service Committee, an agency that helped war-torn Europe after World War 11. I often heard Lotta Hitschmanova on CBC radio and television commercials asking for donations for the USC "an agency with a heart, 56 Sparks Street, Ottawa."
One of the vacant buildings could house a Canadian version of Madame Tussaud's Wax Museum.





Saturday, February 15, 2020

Why are there so many vacant buildings near Parliament Hill?

A November 1, 2019 article:
     "While 19 of the 38 street level shops on Sparks Street's north side are either vacant or construction offices...archival photos show a a much different past. (CBC Ottawa, The heyday of Spark Streets north side.)

Blocks 1,2 and 3 are being redeveloped. The property outlined in blue is the Parliamentary Precinct.
Vacant.
90 Wellington.
100 Wellington
67 Sparks
93 Sparks
183 Sparks
185 Sparks
CIBC bank - 119 Sparks
179 Sparks
Buildings on the Mall that were privatized,
Thomas D'Arcy McGee - 90 Sparks.
The Parliamentary Precinct - Eroding Boundaries
Recent years have seen a return to the confusion and contested boundaries of the early 20th century. In the seventies, because of accommodation pressures on the Hill, Parliamentary activities were moved south of Wellington with the conversion of the Metropolitan Life Building (Wellington Building) for House of Commons use. This blurring of boundaries and the confusion about the relationship of the Parliamentary Precinct to the city continued with the purchase and lease of additional space for Parliamentary use south of Wellington Street.
At the same time, the approach to departmental accommodation became less controlled. Once again, private sector interests began to put up speculative high rise developments which were then leased to the government. The only major government initiative during this period was the construction of large offices complexes in Hull.
In 1973, the Department of Public Works expropriated all the land south of Parliament Hill, between Wellington and Sparks Streets. The intent was to create a "South Block" which would provide Parliamentarians with permanent accommodation south of Wellington Street..It is understandable that Canadians and Parliamentarians would want a comprehensive approach to preserving the Parliamentary Precinct...The possibility of extending the Parliamentary Precinct west from Bank Street to Kent Street is being explored. (Google: Foundation-Building the Future - House of Commons.)
The Confederation Square National Historic Site of Canada encompasses the Bell Building, Central Chambers, Chateau Laurier Hotel, Langevin Block, National Arts Centre, Ottawa Postal Station B, Scottish-Ontario Chamber and Union Station.
Confederation Square was established in 1939 and is the second most important ceremonial centre in Ottawa, after Parliament Hill.
-----------------------------------------------------
Public Works is only offering short-term leases on the Mall according to the November 1, 2019 CBC article "Sparks Street great divide bad for business."





 


Friday, February 14, 2020

Any redevelopment of the Mall in Ottawa should be banned.

Why.
1.)  The federal government expropriated all the buildings and land bounded by Wellington, Elgin, Sparks and Bank Street in 1973, to protect the architectural history of the area and to expand the Parliamentary Precinct. To read the announcement of the expropriation,Google "LIPAD - Search the Canadian Parliament House of Commons".
Go to-Advanced Search - Type in "Sparks Street Mall Ottawa".
Go to "Jean-Eudes Dube, Minister of Public Works - July 20, 1973"
2.)  The Sparks Street Mall is a Heritage Conservation District, protected by Part V of the Ontario Heritage Act and City of Ottawa By-Law # 174-2000.
  Ottawa City Councillor Catherine McKenney is calling for more condominiums on the Mall:
   "Without residences close by (currently) it is difficult to keep it animated and keep people down there. But Sparks Street is perfectly located to take advantage of its location. It's right in the heart of downtown." ("Reigniting an old Sparks in downtown Ottawa" Globe and Mail, March 27, 2017.)
---------------------------------------------------------
National Press Club Block (Block 3)
Primary Use - Office
Address - Wellington Street (144, 150, 180) and Sparks Street (165, 181,185).
Municipality - Ottawa
Land Area - 0.9925 ha.
The buildings located in the National Press Club Block are:
144 Wellington - Sir John A. Macdonald.
150 Wellington - National Press
180 Wellington - Wellington
165 Sparks Street - Booth
185-187 - Dover

Langevin Block Site (Block 1)
Primary Use - Office
Address - 80 Wellington and 59, 63, 65, 67, 69, 75 and 85 Sparks Street.
Municipality - Ottawa
Land Area - 0.6277 ha.
The buildings located in the Langevin Block are:
80 Wellington - Langevin
59 Sparks - Postal Station B.
63 Sparks - Hope
65 Sparks -
67 Sparks -
69 Sparks -
75 Sparks - Saxe
85 Sparks - Blackburn
Block 1.
The Sparks Street Mall. The movie theatre was demolished in the year 2014 so that an 18-story condo building could be constructed on 101 Queen Street.(Photo is from Archives Canada.)









Thursday, February 13, 2020

The following government of Canada buildings are endangered, in my opinion.

They are standing in the way a massive redevelopment project across from Parliament Hill, Ottawa.
1.)  The former Capital Information Centre, 90 Wellington Street is vacant, take a look at the side view. The plaza in front of 90 Wellington was the site of the Rideau Club.
2.)  National Press Building - 150 Wellington Street.
3.)  Canada's 4 Corners - 93 Sparks Street.
4.)  Booth - 165 Sparks Street.
5.)  Senate of Canada - 140 Wellington.
6.)  Former Union Bank, 128 Wellington.
7.)  Brouse and Slater Buildings - 177-181 Sparks.
8.)  La Promenade - 151 Sparks Street.
9.)  Bank of Nova Scotia - 125 Sparks Street.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The federal government expropriated all of the property bounded by Wellington Street, Elgin Street, Sparks Street and Bank Street, in order to provide more space for parliamentarians, and to save the architectural history of the area.
                                                     
 House of Commons Debates Ottawa    July 20, 1973
Jean-Eudes Dube (Minister of Public Works) Liberal
Hon. Jean-Eudes Dube
     "We have all been aware that to properly house the expanded requirements of Parliament for the generations ahead in a way that would both compliment and preserve the existing architectural beauty of the Parliament Buildings we must enlarge the present parliamentary grounds.
     I wish therefore to announce, Mr. Speaker, that I have today, on behalf of the government, filed a notice of intent to expropriate all of the land and buildings in the area bounded by Wellington Street, Elgin Street, Sparks Street and Bank Street. The purpose of this expropriation is as I have indicated to protect the environment of Parliament from any development which could adversely affect it and simultaneously provide the land for an appropriate expansion of parliamentary facilities and other government requirements. The property of the United States Embassy has been excluded from this expropriation but discussions are well advanced for it's acquisition.
     This action will also provide the National Capital Commission with a splendid opportunity to plan the urban development of this most critical piece of land which is at the heart of the national capital and which constitutes a bridge between Parliament and the City of Ottawa.
     I would like to add a few words, Mr. Speaker, with respect to existing properties and especially the Sparks Street Mall. It is the governments intention that until Parliament's needs have been fully defined, there will be no disturbances of the existing properties. This is especially true of the commercial operations on Sparks Street....I want to assure everyone that on the Mall it will be business as usual.
     Further, it is the government's intention that when a plan is developed for the area, including the architecture of the buildings, space will continue to be provided for commercial operations facing Sparks Street so that the present character of the Mall will be preserved and enhanced.
     We are proud of the outstanding appearance and setting of the Parliament of Canada. It is as impressive as any in the world. I think we will all agree that we have a duty to preserve its dignity, grace and beauty for the years ahead, in accordance with the fundamental position it occupies in the life of the nation."
Walter David Baker Progressive Conservative.
Mr. Walter Baker (Grenville-Carleton)
     Mr. Speaker, let me say that on behalf of Her Majesty's Loyal opposition we welcome this announcement today and commend the government for taking this important step...I would say that the most significant aspect of this announcement is the aspect of control. Parliament Hill is recognized as a place of unparalleled architectural beauty. More than that, it is the symbol and the centre of our national life. As such it deserves protection from the conflicts and differences in points of view that arise between municipalities and developers on land use, even if they are well intentioned. This announcement today will ensure that the people of Canada whose national capital this city is will have a part in the development of its centre."


Wednesday, February 12, 2020

Is it a coincidence, that many government buildings on the Mall in Ottawa are vacant.

In November of 2019 the CIBC Bank closed their main branch on 119 Sparks Street in Ottawa.
In November of 2019 Global News reported that many government buildings on the Mall are empty. "NCC approves final plan for Sparks Street revitalization." November 21, 2019.
On February 3, 2020 the federal government announced plans to redevelop an entire city block across from Parliament Hill. An international design competition has been launched. The I.M. Pei Company, creator of the Louvre Pyramid in Paris, France, has already signed on to the project.
Modern buildings up to 32 stories high will be constructed on Wellington Street and Sparks Street.
We have learned nothing from the Chateau Laurier debacle.
The government of Canada appropriated Blocks 1, 2 and 3 in 1973 in order to save them from what is happening now.

All of these buildings are owned by the people of Canada. 

Bank of Nova Scotia - 125 Sparks.
Former CIBC Bank- 119 Sparks.
Booth - 165 Sparks.
Canada's Four Corners - 93 Sparks.
Bate - 109-111 Sparks.
Blackburn - 85 Sparks.
Brouse - 181-183 Sparks.
Postal Station B - 47-59 Sparks.
Slater - 177-179 Sparks.
Saxe - 75 Sparks.
Hope - 61-63 Sparks.
Birks - 107 Sparks.
Dover - 185-187 Sparks.
This is what PWGSC envisioned for the Mall in 2007:
     "Block 3, between O'Connor and Bank Street, contains the Wellington Building redeveloped for swing space, the National Press Building and a series of others facing Sparks Street which could be combined as new infill, retaining the facades." (Parliamentary and Judicial Precinct Area Site Capacity and Long Term Development - Page 87.)
Facadism is an architectural and construction practice whereby only the outer shell of a building is retained. Usually the front. Office and residential towers are then constructed behind the shell.
Are the Brouse and Slater Buildings in the Danja Zone?
They are co-located at 177-181 Sparks Street. The top floors are vacant I believe.











Tuesday, February 11, 2020

Public Works wanted to preserve historic buildings on Wellington Street, Ottawa during the year 2010.

Long-Term Vision and Plan for the Parliamentary Precinct.
     "PWGSC is the custodian of the buildings and grounds within the area surrounding Parliament Hill, known as the Parliamentary Precinct. Part of this important mandate is to maintain the historical and architectural integrity of these assets."
Google: Archived Treasury Board Wellington Street---ARCHIVED Treasury Board of Canada.
Now the department is planning to demolish many of the landmarks because "they are past their life cycle."

Bill S-210 An Act to Amend the National Capital Act

Comments on SkyScraper Page about the redevelopment of Block B, with Metcalfe Street to the east, O'Connor Street to the west, Wellington Street to the north and Sparks Street to the south.
"I can't even begin to imagine what could come out of a design competition that includes 2 historic bank buildings, a former embassy and ... 70's office tower. My biggest fear is that most of these buildings might be demolished with only the facade saved."
"I hope to see the parking lot plaza (former Rideau Club site) developed into new 3-4 storey buildings and the 70's block demolished and replaced with a residential tower or hotel."
"I find it concerning that they seem to be discussing razing this entire block. An old bank was converted into archives space about a decade ago. The spectacular old CIBC building is on this block, recently closed."

Don't tear down any heritage buildings on Wellington Street -Opinion-The Hill Times, February 10, 2020.

Parliamentary and Judicial Precinct Area : Site Capacity and Long Term Development Plan, Page 89 of 148.
"The federally owned blocks 1, 2 and 3, facing the Parliament Buildings, are required to have "medium profile buildings" in order to protect the visual integrity of the Parliamentary Lawn composition. The height limit for the buildings facing Wellington Street is 108 metres above sea level. The height limit for the buildings facing Sparks Street is 113 metres a.s.l".
----------------------------------------------------------
Conversion of metres to storys, online calculator:
108 metres - 32 storys.
113 metres - 34 storys.

Evidence - OGGO (39-2) No. 13-February 14, 2008.
(0935)
"The buildings potentially on the auction block include such special purpose structures as the National Film Board building in Montreal, the Library and Archives Building in Ottawa and the Film Preservation Centre in Gatineau."
Mr. James Moore: "The Liberals had an RFP to sell more than 360 federal government buildings. We've sold seven."
Mrs. Natalie Bull (Executive Director, Heritage Canada Foundation): You might ask why the Heritage Canada Foundation is interested in this topic and why we've been invited. The federal government is a major property holder and counts more than 1,300 designated buildings in its inventory...The 35 buildings in the real estate study included many heritage buildings such as the Dominion Building in Toronto, the National Printing Bureau in Gatineau, the East Memorial in Ottawa and the Wellington Building that we're sitting in today...Our concerns fall in two areas. One is the important role of the federal government as a trustee of legacy buildings. Our second concern is the risk that heritage buildings faces when they leave the federal inventory.
Federal buildings are about accommodating civil servants, but they do a lot more than that. Traditionally they were designed to make a big impression and do reflect our ideals as a nation. They were built to last as public landmarks and monuments and they really reflect the federal presence in towns and cities across the country. They were also designed to demonstrate high standards of design and construction, and they often showcased some of our best architects. In short, we would say that they represent a legacy that belongs to all taxpayers.
Mr. Mario Silva (Davenport, Lib.): ...I think you're absolutely right that the collection we have of buildings and heritage assets across the country is quite fundamental to our country's essence of what we are as a people and as a nation. It's really the soul of what Canada is all about. If we destroy that we really destroy our history.
------------------------------------------------------------------
128 Wellington and 140 Wellington are facing demolition or facadism:
The Union Bank Building and Senate of Canada would be protected by Bill S-208, an Act to Amend the National Capital Act:
Section 2 of the National Capital Act amendment, building or work of national significance pertains to:
d.) the Victoria Building located at 140 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
j.) any place that has been commemorated as a historic place under paragraph 3 (a) of the Historic Sites and Monuments Act;
l.) any prescribed building or work.
Also, there would be a 500 m or 1,640 foot buffer zone pertaining to the demolition, alteration or construction of new buildings on a parcel of land near a work of national significance.
The Parliament Hill Complex is a National Historic Site of Canada.

The First Reading of Bill S-208 was December 10, 2019.
The Second Reading was December 12, 2019.
















Heritage buildings in Canada are not protected.

  The CPR wanted to demolish the Summerhill train station during the early 1970's. The clock tower was modeled after St. Mark's Campanile in Venice, Italy. Recently sold to a developer.

The former North Toronto CPR station, 10 Scrivener. (Photo is from Toronto Railway Historical.)
  Heritage preservationist Paul Oberman was arrested for lying down in front of a bulldozer demolishing a Downsview aircraft hangar.
                                                   

The Federal Department of Fisheries and Oceans privatized its entire portfolio of lighthouses, more than 1,000.
                                                 
Prison for Women National Historic Site of Canada, 40 Sir John A. Macdonald Boulevard, Kingston, Ontario. The new owner is creating condos and retail space in the building, and residential towers will be constructed on the land.




Facadism is inappropriate for Wellington Street, Ottawa.

Facadism - where only the facade or front of a building is preserved.
 Montgomery's Tavern National Historic Site of Canada, 2384 Yonge Street, Toronto Ontario. The former Postal Station K.
The Kingston Penitentiary National Historic Site of Canada, 560 King Street West.
The Distillery District World Heritage Site, Toronto, Ontario. A filming location for the television program Murdoch Mysteries.
The Air Canada Centre then Scotiabank arena, 40 Bay Street Toronto. A former Canada Post mail processing plant. (Wikipedia photo.)


Monday, February 10, 2020

The redevelopment of Wellington Street should be suspended.


Parliament Hill green space will be lost and heritage buildings demolished. And 32-storey modern buildings are inappropriate for this location. Have we learned nothing from the Chateau Laurier controversy.
Definitions
Infill - buildings that are constructed on vacant or underused properties, or between existing buildings.
Facadism - demolishing most of a building and leaving only the front or facade.

According to the document "Parliamentary and Judicial Precinct Area Site Capacity and Long Term Development Plan" :
---there will be height restrictions pertaining to any new developments on Wellington and Sparks Street. The condominium tower located at 101 Queen Street looks pretty tall to me. The National Capital Commission owns the land on which the reResidences by Ashcroft were built.
---Block 1 between Elgin and Metcalfe Street contains:
the Langevin Building.
the Postal Station and several small buildings which could be combined for an infill while retaining their facades. (Page 87.)
---Block 2 between Metcalfe and O'Connor Streets contains:
the former American Embassy.
La Promenade.
Victoria and a series of small buildings, and is the site of the Capital Information Centre. The Fisher Building and La Promenade could be redeveloped. (La Promenade or the Valour Building on 151 Sparks is at the end of its life cycle according to Public Works and will most likely be flattened.)
---Block 3 between O'Connor and Bank Street contains:
the Wellington Building redeveloped for swing space.
the National Press Building.
a series of others facing Sparks Street which could be combined as new infill, retaining the facades.

---(The height limit for structures facing Wellington Street will be 108 meters or 32 storeys according to this document, page 89/148, while the height limit for buildings facing Sparks Street will be 113 meters or 34 storeys. Until 1965 there was a height limitation of 45.5 meters or 13 storeys in downtown Ottawa, so that the Peace Tower could dominate the landscape.)
---infill between the Confederation Building and Justice Buildings.
---proposed infill next to the former American Embassy.
---infill of the West and East Block courtyards.(page 30.)
--------------------------------------
The federal government bought all of the properties on Wellington facing Parliament Hill in 1973, in order to preserve them. And Senator Serge Joyal created Bill S-203 in December 2019 to save the buildings. Bill S-203 An Act to amend the National Capital Act (buildings or works of national significance) has already passed the First Reading.
Properties that will be protected:
a.) the grounds in the City of Ottawa bounded by Wellington Street, the Rideau Canal, the Ottawa River and Kent Street, known as Parliament Hill, and any buildings or works located on those grounds;
b.) the Senate of Canada Building, located at 2 Rideau Street in the City of Ottawa;
c.) the building located at 1 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
d.) the Victoria Building, located at 140 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
e.) the Sir John A. Macdonald Building, located at 144 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
f.) the Wellington Building, located at 180 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
g.) the Confederation Building, located at 229 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
h.) the Justice Building, located at 249 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
i.) the Supreme Court of Canada Building, located at 301 Wellington Street in the City of Ottawa;
j.) any place that has been commemorated as a historic place under paragraph 3 (a) of the Historic Sites and Monuments Board.
k.) a national historic site as defined by subsection 2 (1) of the Parks Canada Agency Act;
l.) any prescribed building or work.
----------------------------------------------
Many landmarks will be saved by Bill S-203:
1.)  the Central Experimental Farm, Carling Avenue. Designated a National Historic Site of Canada by the the Historic Sites and Monuments Board. The National Capital Commission gave a hospital corporation 50 acres of the Farm.
A 1998 Historic Sites and Monuments document pertaining to the Experimental Farm and Observatory campus.

2.)  The Dominion Observatory campus near Carling Avenue.
3.)  The Connaught Building.
4.)  National Arts Centre.
5.)  East Memorial Building on Wellington.
6.)  West Memorial Building on Wellington.
7.)  Library and Archives Canada, 395 Wellington. A new federal Library and Archives Building is being constructed on Lebreton Flats, which will most likely replace the current one.
8.)  the Chateau Laurier Hotel.

Blocks 1, 2 and 3 opposite Parliament Hill.



Sunday, February 9, 2020

The map is part of a June 2012 Report of the Auditor General of Canada. (PWGSC.) "The Parliamentary Precinct consists of all Crown-owned buildings occupied by the House of Commons, the Senate, and the Library of Parliament. Current and planned jurisdiction areas of the House of Commons Parliamentary Precinct area are highlighted on the map."

A photograph I took of Princess Diana on Parliament Hill, June 20, 1983. The former Langevin Block can be seen in the background.

Public Services and Procurement is now planning to redevelop property directly across the street from Parliament Hill.
The Americans would never call Lafayette Park a prime piece of real estate, and they would never permit the construction of condominiums on the land. Lafayette Park is directly across the street from the White House in Washington, D.C. My family and I visited the site when we lived in Richmond, Virginia during the early 1960's.
     How disrespectful, for the government of Canada to launch an international design competition for Wellington Street and the Sparks Street Mall. Several buildings are facing demolition. When federal buildings are privatized they lose all heritage designation and protection. Canada's Maple Leaf Flag and Coat of Arms are stripped from the facade.









Save the Greenbelt.

     The Greenbelt was supposed to be untouchable, a living memorial in perpetuity to Canadians who died fighting in foreign wars.  However "The City of Ottawa has identified more than 13, 700 acres of the Greenbelt that could be developed without damaging the integrity of the Capital's most treasured landmark." (From:" Ottawa Greenbelt Development Under Review" June 11, 2008, PondPine.com.)
     Is it a coincidence, that government buildings on the Nepean Research Farm, Fallowfield Road and Shirley's Bay are in critical condition?("More than one in four area federal buildings in poor or critical condition." by Bruce Deachman, Ottawa Citizen January 21, 2020.)
     When Jim Prentice was the federal Environment Minister he refused to privatize any of the 49,400 acres of land.
House of Commons Debates Ottawa May 25, 2010.
Mr. Marcel Proulx (Hull-Aylmer, Lib.)
  "The Liberal members from the National Capital Region, the member for Ottawa South, the member for Ottawa-Vanier and myself, are calling for better protection of the greenbelt...Together, the City of Ottawa and the NCC can do whatever they want with this land. We believe this green space must be protected from developers...We are the trustees and custodians of our region's heritage."
Organizations that are trying to preserve the land.
Alliance to Save Our Greenbelt.
Save Our Greenspace!
Ontario Chapter/Sierra Club of Canada.
 Definition of a National Interest Land Mass.
The National Interest Land Mass (NILM) identifies lands that are essential to the achievement of the NCC's mandate. Lands identified within the NILM are required to support the symbolism, functions, and natural and cultural landscape qualities of Canada's Capital. A NILM designation indicates a formal expression of the federal government's interest in the long-term use of these lands in a manner that supports Canada's Capital.
National Interest Land Mass properties.
Mer Bleue - an 8,648 acre conservation area.
The former Energy, Mines and Resources campus on Booth Street.
The Central Experimental Farm, Carling Avenue.


Saturday, February 8, 2020

CN Rail owned most of the tracks in eastern Canada.

One year before the Crown corporation was privatized...
House of Commons Debates, Ottawa    February 7, 1994.

Mr. Alex Shepherd (Durham)
     "Mr. Speaker, those of us who are proud Canadians are offended that CP Rail has decided to change its company logo into what in effect looks like the Canadian flag becoming or being subsumed into the American flag,
     It is not just Canadians who are offended by this logo. This logo has also been challenged in the United States for defaming the American flag. Regardless of CP's rights as a private company to choose any logo it wants, Canadians should have a voice in this matter. CP Rail is a company that Canadian taxpayers have helped to establish through subsidies, outright gifts of land and other means.
     I note that most of the tracks in eastern Canada are owned by CN and more precisely the taxpayers of Canada. Currently CN, which displays the Canadian flag on its trains, and CP are in negotiation for consolidation of rail services in eastern Canada. I would like to bring this matter to the attention of the House so that we can convey our desire to have the Canadian flag and not the offensive logo of CP Rail flying over taxpayers' property in eastern Canada."
The CPR logo from 1993 until 1996.
After the Crown corporation was sold off the CN Tower became "Canada's National Tower."

Friday, February 7, 2020

Books about endangered federal properties in Canada.

The future of the Dominion Observatory Campus near Carling Avenue, Ottawa is bleak because:
1.) The Gonzales Observatory, 302 Denison Road Victoria, BC (pictured on the cover of this book) was sold to the City of Victoria For $35,000 dollars in 1987. The property was divested through a Privy Council Order-in-Council.
 2.) A health care facility is building a new hospital on 50 acres of land near the Dominion Observatory, Ottawa. The hospital has indicated that they do not want "irregularly shaped parcels of land" and the National Capital Commission said that many heritage buildings could be relocated or demolished.
2.)  During the mid-1990's the federal government wanted to flatten the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory.
3.) Astronomer Arthur Covington wrote a letter to Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau in 1971 asking the PM to save the Carling Avenue Observatory.
4.)  The South Azimuth will be removed because the hospital has to widen Maple Drive. The North Azimuth was removed when Carling Avenue was widened many years ago.
5.)  The hospital wants more than 50 acres of land in order to expand, they are building laboratories, medical offices, housing for interns, research facilities, etc.




------------------------------------------------
A 1968 report by E.R. Fisher.
A 2007 report by Rob Sampson.




Wednesday, February 5, 2020

More federal government property sales.

1.)  The Dominion Coal Blocks east of Fernie, British Columbia. Parcel 73 covered 2,000 hectares of land, while Parcel 83 encompassed over 18,000 hectares of land. Since the year 1905 the people of Canada owned the Dominion Coal Blocks.
The Dominion Coal Blocks were part of the Natural Resources Canada portfolio.
2.)  Ridley Terminals Inc., Prince Rupert, British Columbia. During the last century, Canadian companies were Limited or Ltd., while American companies were defined by the terms Incorporated or Inc. An influential group called The Fraser Institute has been calling for the privatization of government real estate in BC for years, that includes:
The Ridley Terminals
Canada Post
CMHC
CBC
The Department of Fisheries and Oceans
Forestry Canada
Canada Place in Vancouver, with its iconic white sails. The pavilion was built for Expo 86 using millions of tax dollars.

3.)  Toronto Harbour Commission Building, 60 Harbour Street, Toronto Ontario.