Kingston Penitentiary, 560 King Street West Kingston, Ontario. |
Once the CLC acquires the title to a federal property, it is almost impossible for the government to repossess it:
"If social forces can become involved before federal property is transferred to Canada Lands, there is a greater likelihood of influence over the ultimate disposal, since it remains in the sphere of public demands upon government. Once Canada Lands Company has title the issue shifts to a business model; Canada Lands must operate according to commercial principles.
In these conditions, bringing public influence and political considerations to bear becomes much more difficult." (From: "Sites of Governance: Multilevel Governing and Policy Making in Canada" - 2012 edited by Robert Young and Martin Horak. McGill-Queen's University Press.)
A Tale of Two Experimental Farms
Ravenwood Farm and Upton Farm, Agriculture Canada Experiential Farms located in Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island.
Federal Minister of Agriculture Gerry Ritz and PEI politicians saved the Ravenwood Experimental Farm in Charlottetown.
However, Upton Farm was already owned by the CLC by the time time local citizens began protesting. Kristen Connor wrote to the prime minister of Canada, and received a letter from a federal minister:
"They informed me that they were only policy directors of Canada Lands. Canada Lands is an independent organization that they cannot interfere with under any circumstances." (Kristen Connor interview with David Bulger, "Sites of Governance:Multilevel Governing and Policy Making in Canada" Page 65).
Is the Canada Lands Company more powerful than the Prime Minister of Canada, more influential than the Members of Parliament whom we elect to represent our interests?
Does the term "arms-length Crown corporation" mean that the Canada Lands Company is not accountable to the citizens of Canada? Crown land is collectively owned by the citizens of this country and we have every right to be consulted before our land is privatized, and to veto any plans that are not acceptable. (Including the construction of 25-storey condominium towers, new parking lots and roads.)
Charlottetown Member of Parliament Shawn Murphy called for an 18-month moratorium on the redevelopment of Upton Farm. By the fall of 2006, the CLC was consulting developers, and Charlottetown City Council approved the rezoning of the property for residential development.
Kristen Connor said that the CLC held public consultations, but the meetings always centered around the fact that subdivisions would be created.
Upton Farm - See the YouTube video featuring the song "Help Save Old Upton Farm".
Preserving the Kingston Penitentiary is not an option for the CLC, because Canada Lands is a commercial Crown corporation. They have to build high rise condominiums and townhouses in Kingston in order to make a profit, even if that means demolishing buildings, guard towers and perimeter walls at the penitentiary.
No comments:
Post a Comment