Monday, June 19, 2023

NCC Federal Site Review for the New Civic Campus of the Ottawa Hospital, Nov. 2016.

Site 7: CEF: Baseline Road-Merivale Road. Key Strengths 

  • Ideal parcel shape and size.
  • Very good road access.
  • Low cost implications for federal government.
  • Good access to Highway 417. 
Key Weaknesses
  • Irreversible impact on the experimental fields and shelterbelts, elements identified as having national significance.
  • Displaces agricultural plots subject to research.
  • Does not conform to federal planning framework for the site.
  • Not in close proximity to transit-oriented development or future urban intensification.
  • Poor connectivity to rapid rail transit.
Site 9: CEF - Carling Avenue (west) Key Strengths 
  • Ideal parcel shape and size.
  • Very good road access.
  • Very good access to Highway 417.
  • Proximity to existing Civic Hospital would facilitate transition.
  • Low cost implications for federal government.
  • No known physical vulnerabilities.
Key Weaknesses
  • Irreversible impact on the experimental fields and shelterbelts, views and cultural landscape elements identified as having national significance as part of the Central Experimental Farm National Historic Site.
  • Displaces agricultural plots subject to research.
  • Does not conform to federal planning framework for site.
  • Not in close proximity to transit-oriented development or future urban plans.
  • Poor connectivity to rapid rail transit.
Site 10 - CEF - Carling Avenue (central) Key Strengths
  • Ideal parcel shape.
  • Very good access to Highway 417.
  • Proximity to existing Civic Hospital would facilitate transition.
  • No known physical vulnerabilities.
Key Weaknesses
  • Irreversible impact on buildings, experimental fields, views and cultural landscape elements identified as having national significance as part of the Central Experimental Farm National Historic Site.
  • Displaces agricultural plots subject to research and federal offices.
  • Poor connectivity to rapid rail transit.
Site 11 - CEF - Carling Avenue (east) Key Strengths
  • Within 400 m of existing rapid transit station.
  • Very good road access.
  • Very good access to Highway 417.
  • Proximity to existing Civic Hospital would facilitate transition.
  • Good potential for active transportation.
  • Low cost implications for federal government.
  • Great city-building potential.
  • Site topography and configuration could generate great design.
Key Weaknesses
  • Impact on cultural heritage due to intrusion into boundary of Central Experimental Farm National Historic Site, proximity to UNESCO World Heritage Site, and presence of heritage buildings.
  • Moderate geotechnical challenges.
  • Site topography and configuration could create design challenges.
  • Does not conforms to federal planning framework for the site. (All info is from pages 30 and 31of 256 pages.)

No comments:

Post a Comment